Store leaderboard

Every store, rated.

We rate 161 stores: 88 in our live price comparison plus 73 store profiles (brand e-stores, department stores, online luxury and resale). Each gets a transparent reputation score built from public reviews and the shipping, returns, duties, authenticity and payment terms on its own pages. Every source is linked and dated; anything we could not find says “Not stated”.

88stores in our comparison
73store profiles (brands, department, resale)
17921live offers tracked
129stores with public review data
127with returns terms captured
154stores with a reputation score

The full ranking.

Everything fits on screen, with no sideways scrolling. Sort by any key metric, filter by shipping and returns terms, and open “More details” on a store for every sourced fact with its source link and check date.

Badges
1
87
Excellent · excl. price
4.162.9k reviews · Trustpilot
2–4 daysFree over £400
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
30 daysFree returns
PayPal, Apple PayBNPL: Klarna, Afterpay, Tamara
Guarantee
Profile onlyVerified terms
2
83
Excellent · excl. price
4.620.9k reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over $400
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
30 daysFree returns
PayPal, Apple Pay
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
3
79
Strong · excl. price
4.1123.8k reviews · Trustpilot
8–10 daysFree over $350 (US)
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
60 daysReturn fee
PayPal, Apple PayBNPL: Klarna
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
5
73
Strong · excl. price
4.4573 reviews · Trustpilot
2-day (US)Free 2-day (US)
—
30 daysLabel provided returns
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
8
69
Strong · excl. price
3.66,100 reviews · Trustpilot
3–5 daysFree over $400 (US)
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
28 daysReturn fee
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
9
69
Strong
4.152.8k reviews · Trustpilot
—
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
30 daysYou pay returns
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
11
68
Strong · excl. price
3.953.5k reviews · Trustpilot
4–5 days
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
30 daysCost deducted returns
—
Authentication process
Profile onlyMarketplaceVerified terms
12
68
Strong · excl. price
4.213.5k reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over €180 (Italy)
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
Window not statedReturn fee
—
—
Profile only
13
67
Strong
4.613k reviews · Trustpilot
2–4 daysFree over $350 (US)
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
14 days
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
15
66
Strong
4.5863 reviews · Trustpilot
1–6 daysItaly 1–3 days, Europe 3–5, elsewhere 3–6; ships within 1–3 business days
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 daysYou pay returns
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
16
66
Strong
4.373 reviews · Store listing
1–2 daysFree over EUR 120
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
10 daysYou pay returns
PayPal
—
In comparisonVerified terms
17
66
Strong · excl. price
3.28,697 reviews · Trustpilot
2–5 daysFree over $400
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
28 daysReturn fee
PayPal, Apple PayBNPL: Klarna (Australia)
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
18
66
Strong · excl. price
4.33,000 reviews · Trustpilot
—
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
30 days
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
21
66
Strong · excl. price
4.15,805 reviews · Trustpilot
—
—
14 daysFree returns
CardsBNPL: Klarna (UK Pay in 3, US Pay in 4)
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
22
65
Provisional · 55% of data
4.889 reviews · Google
2–3 daysAU
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
—
PayPalBNPL: Afterpay, Zip
—
In comparisonVerified terms
24
65
Strong · excl. price
4.117k reviews · Trustpilot
6–12 daysAverage standard delivery in business days; UK Premium next-day on eligible items
—
14 daysCost deducted returns
—
Authentication process
Profile onlyMarketplaceVerified terms
25
64
Provisional · 55% of data
—
5–8 daysFree over $250
—
14 days
—
Authentic stated
In comparisonVerified terms
26
64
Fair · excl. price
3.11,764 reviews · Trustpilot
2-day (US)Free 2-day (US)
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
Window not statedFree returns
PayPal, Apple PayBNPL: Affirm, Klarna, Afterpay
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
27
64
Fair
4.3128.6k reviews · Trustpilot
5–7 daysFree over $200 (US) · £120 (UK)
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
30 daysYou pay returns
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
28
64
Fair
4.5471 reviews · Trustpilot
2–7 daysExpress 2–3 business days outside Italy; standard 3–7 in Europe, 4–6 in the US
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 daysYou pay returns
PayPal, Apple PayBNPL: Klarna
—
In comparisonVerified terms
30
63
Fair · excl. price
4.35,072 reviews · Trustpilot
—
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
15 days
Google PayBNPL: Affirm
Authentication process
Profile onlyMarketplaceVerified terms
34
62
Fair · excl. price
3.812.5k reviews · Trustpilot
1–2 daysUSA after dispatch; EU standard 2–6 days
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
28 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
35
62
Fair
3.7111 reviews · Trustpilot
1–2 daysFree over EUR 400
—
14 daysReturn fee
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
36
61
Fair
3.4173 reviews · Trustpilot
1–3 daysFree over EUR 80
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 daysYou pay returns
Apple Pay, Google PayBNPL: Klarna (not for online releases/limited editions)
—
In comparisonVerified terms
38
60
Fair · excl. price
1.7203 reviews · Trustpilot
—
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
30 daysFree returns
PayPal, Apple PayBNPL: Tabby, Tamara, Taly
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
40
60
Fair
4.197 reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over €300 (Italy/EU)
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 daysReturn fee
PayPal
—
In comparisonVerified terms
41
60
Fair · excl. price
3.833.2k reviews · Trustpilot
—
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 daysYou pay returns
CardsBNPL: Klarna
Guarantee
Profile onlyMarketplaceVerified terms
42
60
Fair · excl. price
3.6138.3k reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over $250 (US)
—
14 days
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
44
60
Fair · excl. price
3.01,952 reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over £300 (UK)
—
30 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile only
47
58
Provisional · 55% of data
—
Not statedFree over $100 (CA)
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
30 daysYou pay returns
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
48
58
Provisional · 31% of data
—
3–5 daysUS standard delivery, plus 1–3 days processing
—
30 days
—
—
Profile only
52
57
Fair
3.5231 reviews · Trustpilot
4–5 daysFree over €300 (Italy)
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 daysReturn fee
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
54
57
Fair
2.58 reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over $50
—
30 daysYou pay returns
Apple Pay, Google Pay
—
In comparisonVerified terms
55
57
Fair
4.21,451 reviews · Trustpilot
3–5 daysGenerally 3–5 working days via FedEx; Italy 2–3 days via TNT
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
Window not statedYou pay returns
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
57
56
Fair
4.4258 reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over EUR 250
—
14 daysYou pay returns
PayPal
—
In comparisonVerified terms
60
55
Fair
4.2150 reviews · Trustpilot
2–6 daysItaly 2–3 business days, Europe 3–4, elsewhere 3–6; dispatched within 2 working days
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 daysReturn fee
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
61
55
Provisional · 31% of data
—
2–4 days
—
30 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
64
54
Fair
3.4642 reviews · Trustpilot
2–6 daysWorldwide
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 days
PayPal, Apple PayBNPL: Klarna, Afterpay
Authentic stated
In comparisonVerified terms
66
54
Fair
3.43,469 reviews · Trustpilot
7–14 daysFree express worldwide shipping
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
—
Apple Pay, Google Pay
Authentic stated
In comparisonVerified terms
69
53
Fair
2.044 reviews · Trustpilot
5–7 daysFree over CAD 150
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 daysCost deducted returns
PayPalBNPL: Afterpay, Sezzle
—
In comparisonVerified terms
70
53
Fair · excl. price
2.01,685 reviews · Trustpilot
1–5 daysUS standard 1–5 days; Europe express 1–2 business days; UAE 2–3; Kuwait, Qatar, Saudi Arabia 3–4
—
30 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
71
53
Fair
3.22 reviews · Trustpilot
—
—
30 days
Google PayBNPL: Klarna, Afterpay, Sezzle
—
In comparison
73
52
Fair · excl. price
3.1294 reviews · Trustpilot
3–6 daysUS standard ground 3–6 business days
—
30 daysReturn fee
CardsBNPL: Klarna, Afterpay
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
75
52
Fair · excl. price
1.8231 reviews · Trustpilot
3–5 daysUS Ground 3–5 business days; EU 2–3 business days
—
30 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
76
52
Fair
4.117k reviews · Trustpilot
6–12 daysAverage standard delivery in business days; UK Premium next-day on eligible items
—
14 daysCost deducted returns
—
Authentication process
In comparisonVerified terms
80
52
Fair
4.332 reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over €200 (Italy)
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 daysYou pay returns
PayPal
—
In comparisonVerified terms
81
51
Fair
3.21 reviews · Trustpilot
1–5 daysFree over AUD 350
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 days
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
82
51
Fair · excl. price
1.7424 reviews · Trustpilot
1–3 daysFree standard shipping (US)
—
30 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
84
50
Fair
2.414 reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree US shipping on orders $250+
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
21 days
CardsBNPL: Affirm
—
In comparisonVerified terms
85
50
Fair
2.138 reviews · Trustpilot
Same/next day (UAE)Free in UAE; $300 (US)
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
30 daysFree returns
Apple Pay, Google PayBNPL: Tabby, Tamara, Klarna
—
In comparisonVerified terms
86
50
Fair · excl. price
1.83,722 reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over $300 (US)
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
14 daysFree returns
CardsBNPL: Klarna
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
87
50
Fair · excl. price
2.05,133 reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over £39
—
30 daysFree returns
CardsBNPL: Klarna
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
89
50
Fair · excl. price
3.1241 reviews · Trustpilot
—
—
7 daysReturn fee
—
Authentication process
Profile onlyMarketplaceVerified terms
91
50
Fair · excl. price
2.1361 reviews · Trustpilot
6–12 daysFree over €150 (Germany)
—
14 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
93
50
Provisional · 55% of data
—
1–5 daysItaly 1–2 working days, EU 2–3, elsewhere 4–5 (after up to 48 business hours processing)
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 daysYou pay returns
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
95
50
Fair · excl. price
1.81,627 reviews · Trustpilot
3–6 daysFree over $75 (US)
—
30 daysReturn fee
PayPal, Apple PayBNPL: Klarna, Afterpay
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
97
49
Weak · excl. price
1.611k reviews · Trustpilot
1–5 daysUS fashion standard 1–5 business days (UPS)
—
30 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
99
49
Weak · excl. price
1.62,063 reviews · Trustpilot
1–5 daysUS standard 1–5 business days from the shipping email; Alaska and Hawaii 5–7
—
30 daysFree returns
Apple Pay, PayPal
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
101
48
Weak · excl. price
1.51,271 reviews · Trustpilot
About 5 business days (US)US standard, orders placed by 3pm ET
—
30 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
104
48
Weak · excl. price
1.71,147 reviews · Trustpilot
5–13 daysInternational orders via ESW
IncludedDDP: no surprise bill
Window not statedFree returns
PayPal, Apple PayBNPL: Afterpay, Klarna
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
116
46
Weak · excl. price
1.51,515 reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over $99 (US)
—
30 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
118
45
Weak
1.584 reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over $75
—
30 daysYou pay returns
PayPalBNPL: Afterpay, Affirm, Zip
—
In comparisonVerified terms
122
44
Weak
1.725 reviews · Trustpilot
—
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
30 daysYou pay returns
PayPal
—
In comparisonVerified terms
125
43
Weak · excl. price
1.3583 reviews · Trustpilot
1–4 daysFree express delivery (US)
—
20 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
129
42
Weak
1.620 reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over $250
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
7 daysFree returns
CardsBNPL: Affirm
—
In comparisonVerified terms
131
42
Weak · excl. price
1.513.2k reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over $50 (US, Members)
—
60 days
—
—
Profile onlyVerified terms
132
42
Weak · excl. price
1.41,364 reviews · Trustpilot
3–7 daysFree over A$99 (AU)
—
30 days
CardsBNPL: Afterpay ($100–$2,000), Zip
—
Profile only
133
42
Weak · excl. price
3.18,300 reviews · Trustpilot
—
—
—
Apple Pay, Google PayBNPL: Klarna
None
Profile onlyMarketplaceVerified terms
135
41
Weak · excl. price
1.7546 reviews · Trustpilot
1–6 daysUS 1–6 business days; Mexico 5–7 business days
—
30 daysFree returns
—
—
Profile only
138
40
Weak · excl. price
1.6192.3k reviews · Trustpilot
Not statedFree over £15
—
28 days
CardsBNPL: Klarna
—
Profile only
143
40
Weak · excl. price
2.168 reviews · Trustpilot
—
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 days
—
—
Profile only
147
37
Weak · excl. price
1.3112 reviews · Trustpilot
2–5 daysStandard delivery in business days; Express 1–2 days
—
—
—
Guarantee
Profile only
148
37
Weak
2.2304 reviews · Trustpilot
2–7 daysUK 2–4 working days; international 3–7 working days
Extra at deliveryDAP: buyer pays on delivery
14 daysFree returns
—
—
In comparisonVerified terms
154
26
Weak · excl. price
1.224.3k reviews · Trustpilot
—
—
—
—
Buyer protection
Profile onlyMarketplaceVerified terms

Tap “More details” on a store for delivery regions, free-shipping thresholds, duties, return costs, refund speed, customer service and price-match, each with its source and check date.

The numbers, charted.

All charts use the same data as the table. Hover or tap a point for detail.

Reviews vs price competitiveness

Each dot is a store. Right = better public reviews, up = cheaper more often. Dot size = matched products.

Score breakdown: top 3 vs all stores

Average component score, 0–100.

Where we find the lowest price

Share of matched items where the store is cheapest (stores with 15+ compared offers).

Public review ratings

How many stores fall in each rating band (primary public profile).

What shoppers get

Share of stores with each shopper-friendly term stated on their own pages. “Not stated” counts as no.

How we score.

The FASHIONDEALS Reputation Score runs 0–100 (shown as 0–5 stars). It is a weighted average of the components below, using only the components we have real data for.

30%

Customer reviews

Count-weighted average rating across public review profiles we found (Trustpilot first, then BBB/Yelp/Google/Birdeye store ratings), smoothed toward 3.5 so a handful of reviews cannot top the table. Rating 1 = 0, rating 5 = 100.

20%

Price competitiveness

Our own data, only for stores in our comparison: 60% how often the store has the lowest price on items we match across 2+ stores, 40% its average saving versus the other stores (−10% to +15% mapped to 0–100). Needs 15+ compared offers. Left out and re-weighted for store-profile-only stores.

10%

Delivery

What the store publishes: a free-shipping offer or threshold, how widely it ships, stated delivery times and an express option. Shipping prices and times are read from the store’s own pages.

10%

Duties transparency

Duties and taxes included at checkout (DDP) score best; extra charges paid on delivery (DAP) score low. Only scored when the store states which applies.

15%

Returns

Return window (30+ days = best) combined with who pays: free returns best, customer-paid worst; store-credit-only is penalised; no standard returns is the lowest.

10%

Authenticity

An independent authentication step (100), an explicit authenticity guarantee or direct-from-brand sourcing (80), authentic products stated (55), buyer protection or optional verification only (35), or no item authentication (20). Based on the published policy; we have not verified any store independently.

5%

Payment options

Cards (30), PayPal (20), Apple Pay or Google Pay (20), buy-now-pay-later such as Klarna, Afterpay, Tabby or Tamara (20) and local methods (10), as listed on the store’s pages.

Confidence. If a store is missing components, the score is pulled toward 50 in proportion to the missing weight, and the store is flagged provisional when under 60% of the weight is available. Provisional stores are ranked but can’t take a podium place. Fields we could not find show “Not stated” and are never scored or estimated.

Store profiles without price data. Stores we cannot crawl yet have no price data, so that component is left out and the others are re-weighted to 100%. Their score is labelled “excl. price” and is not a like-for-like comparison with stores that also have price data.

Real data only. Review scores, counts and shopper policies come from public sources linked on each store page and were checked on 2026-10-27. Anything we could not find shows “Not stated” or “n/a”; we never estimate. Company revenue is not shown or scored. Public review counts change daily; search-engine snapshots of review pages can lag the live page. Our own price statistics use each store’s listed price converted to USD, so local VAT treatment can differ between stores. A store’s score is not a recommendation to buy; rules and policies change, so always read the store’s current terms.

Updates. Our own statistics (products, offers, cheapest %, saving, size links, coverage) are rebuilt on every catalogue refresh. Researched fields carry their own check date.